5 Mistakes HBO made in the Larry-Magic Special

So I just finished watching the HBO Sports special on Larry and Magic, and you gotta say HBO did a great job digging up all the amazing footage (Magic and Bird playing together on the pre-NBA US Team, Bird’s emotional pregame reaction to learning about Magic contracting HIV) and focusing on the relationship between the two in what was an enjoyable and emotional 90 minutes. There were, however, a few items that were left out, left in or over looked that are worth noting:
1. Magic was more popular and well known nationally than Larry going into the 1979 NCAA Championship Game. Huh? First off, Bird was featured on the cover of Sports Illustrated (the Number 1 national sports news source at the time) a year before Magic (in 1977 to Johnson’s cover in ’78) and his second SI cover came two weeks before the title game with Magic. Bird was the one-man wolf-pack of the biggest Cinderella maybe ever, while Johnson was part of Michigan State’s one two punch. Oh, did they forget to mention Senior Forward “Special K” Greg Kelser who lead the Spartans in points and rebounds that season? Or the fact that ISU was on a 30+game winning streak and #1 seed in their bracket (MSU #2 behind Notre Dame)?
2. The Celtics are the white man’s team. Can’t really argue with this because the Celtics of the 80s (especially from 86 and on) were so white they were almost clear. The problem I have is that they picked a story about a black fan from Boston rooting for Magic at Logan airport to try and show that the Celtics were not, nor could they ever, represent black fans. HBO fails to even throw a little credit toward Red and Walter Brown for the following barriers being broken for African American’s in Basketball and Sports in general: The first black NBA player, the first all black starting 5, the first black head coach and the most championships by black head coaches (5). Oh yeah, and the Lakers are one of two teams in NBA history to have never had a black head coach (Magic’s brief stint was on an interim basis).
3. Magic was transformed after the 1984 finals. HBO makes the argument that after “Tragic” Johnson’s mental errors (not as much Larry’s rallying the troops) gave the 1984 Finals to the Celtics, and that Magic asserted himself as the greatest player up to that point with 3 MVP trophies and three more NBA titles. Bull shit. With the 1984 Finals being such a huge success for the NBA and CBS (the league seeing LA-Boston Finals for God willing the next 10 years), they decide to change the 2-2-1-1-1 format to 2-3-2. As Larry once said, “the most important game in a 7-game series is game 5.” After a tying up the ’85 series at 2-games each the Celtics then have to play game 5 in LA instead of a return to 500-degree heat of the Boston Garden where they would have surely swapped wins over the next two games, thus putting Game 7 back in Boston. Magic then follows up that season by taking it in the ass (not like that Isiah) courtesy of the Houston Rockets (the 2nd time that happened in 6 years), then “crushes” the 98% injured Celtics in 1987. Bird’s back makes him a non-factor for the remainder of his career, while the Lakers continue to face little competition in the West (unlike the Celtic battles against Philly in the early 80s and Detroit in the late 80s). In my view, less of a transformation than the cards falling right for Magic and LA.
4. Bird takes the blame for conservative anti-black regression in the 1980s while Magic was a dealt a bad hand by getting HIV. The Special was going so well then they had to get all political. Okay, so make the ridiculous leap that Bird was the poster child for some Republican led pro-white movement in the 80s, but don’t over shadow what Magic’s contracting the HIV virus in the 90s did as a poster child for racists and homophobes for the early part of that decade. Instead of pointing the finger at Johnson’s inability to control his “Johnson,” HBO plays it off as Magic the hard-luck victim. Glossing over the countless women his, somewhat understandably selfish, behavior may have affected or the way he initially reacted to interviews as a podium to brag about the amount of pussy he had plugged (they did show the clip where Magic holds back a smile while taking about fucking 6-girls at once). That being said, they also missed the boat on how his contracting HIV gradually destroyed the fear and social impact that the disease had in the US and the world. When Magic didn’t die, and eventually returned to basketball and even hosted that awful talk show, the monster that was HIV and AIDS did a 180 from a disease that means instant death to something that, with the right treatment and support, can be dealt with and defeated.
5. Bird is thought of as the better player because of the white press. In the prime of their careers (1984-87) Bird was 3-peat MVP (84-86) and made the Finals 4-years in a row (losing in ’85 after being fucked by David Stern and in ’87 by being forced to play with the rest of the squad in wheelchairs). Magic, lands one MVP in ’87 and misses the chance to get swept in 4 games by the greatest NBA team of all time the 1986 Celtics. Sorry, I was there and history don’t lie. Bird was the better player.
NOTE: I will say that HBO Sports should get some credit for quietly declaring Boston to be the greatest Sports city on the planet. They’ve already done documentary-style specials on Ted Williams, Bill Russell, the 1980 US Hockey team and now Larry Bird. It makes you wonder just how much longer til they do something on Belichick (and if anyone gave a shit about the NHL, Bobby Orr).
Ub- Solid writing! Now get back to looking for slutty wake-ups
Bill Simmons ranked Magic over Bird in his book. These are facts.
Boston Sports Guy indeed.
It seems more than any, the city of Boston provides the most compelling backdrop for any type of sports documentary. Storied tradition all around makes outsiders cream. If they can’t beat us, watch our documentaries, study our history, and hope to join us.
No mention of “Curse of the Bambino?” Et tu, Buck?
Omar- how’s the college sports in boston ?
UB bring it today!
It was interesting to hear Bird hurt his back working on his driveway.
My favorite part was where they were saying Bird used to instigate fights to get his brother in because he liked to see him get his ass kicked.
We need more of that in the NBA
Does this name get me laid: who gives a shit.
UB good call on the race thing with the Celtics. I’m shocked HBO didn’t mention all of the good things Red did for blacks on the Celtics.
UB, you forgot to mention that there was way too much Arsenio. A few minutes would have been fine, but he was there every other cut.
Two points, UB:
1. As you mentioned, HBO already did a special on Bill Russell in which they acknowledge everything the Celtics franchise did for African-Americans during his playing and coaching days. That said, Boston in the 70′s and 80′s was the symbol of resurgent, anti-Civil Rights, overt white racism and the Bird-led Celtics were a symbol of that racism. It was less about the team and more about how the people of Boston used the team to support their anti-Black position. HBO was right not to conflate that version of the Celtics with the one they’d covered in the other documentary.
2. It’s hard to say who was the better player, but using Bird’s MVPs is hardly a fair factor. His race WAS a factor to the white media that selected the MVP. But more than that, using MVPs, which is basically a popularity contest, is flawed. By that reasoning, Payton Manning is the greatest player in NFL history and any Bostonian knows that’s BS.
I was there, too, and it’s pretty easy to make a case for Bird or Magic.
wasnt the NBA MVP voted on by sportswriters? You shouldn’t use MVP comparison as a barometer considering it was a mostly white group voting.
Magic was more dynamic. Bird was more fundamentally sound. Either way It’s all ancient Fucking history. I’m going back to look at Eva Mendes
c’mon UB…denying that Boston didn’t embrace Bird more so because he was white is rewriting history…Boston has a history of racism that exists to this day…Mike Wilbon still claims the only place he’s ever been called the n-word to his face was in the old Boston Garden…I don’t really care one way or the other…but getting all bent out of shape by the racial undertones in this documentary is dishonest…Boston loves its white players much more than its black ones…it’s just a fact
hey jack….if wilbon was in the new garden I’d call him one…..guys a jackass
If this argument is going to get all racial, I’m going to have to put some cream in my coffee.
Enjoyed reading this, you make a lot of good points. A few things I was surprised that they missed…
1. Len Bias and how his death affected the 87 Finals and beyond. I know enough has been said about him, but at least mention it.
2. Magic embarrassing himself with multiple comebacks/coaching.
3. Larry’s throwback game against the Trailblazers during his painful last season when he dropped 49 pts and hit an off balance 3 to tie it at the end.
4. Larry’s trash talking was never mentioned.
Also I just thought it was annoying that any of Magic’s bad behavior was passed off as “oh, well there’s Earvin and then there’s Magic”, like he had multiple personality disorder and “Magic” created all of these problems and “Earvin” had to deal with all the repercussions even though he had nothing to do with it. A little absurd I thought.
Ub, I love the way you just re-wrote history. In your mind, the only legitimate Boston-LA series was the one Boston was allowed to play football and won. let me see if I have this right, in 86, LA won because the league changed the playoff format? Did n’t they still have to win four games regardless of the format? And didn’t they wrap the series up by kicking Boston’s ass in the Garden? And 87, Boston was too injured, right? In that final series, both Bird and DJ averaged more than 40 minutes, while McHale averaged 38+. How injured could they have been?
I can’t believe you would even argue that Celtics weren’t the white man’s team. I understand the race barriers the team broke down. But that black guy in the airport was truly representative of a large part of Boston’s black basketball fans. Among black people around that time, there were even more Philly fans than Celtic fans.
I’m going to have to watch the show again because I completely missed the part of the show that portrayed as Bird as the poster child for a republican pro-white movement.
I’m also confused about how you determined the prime of both of their careers to be 1984 to 1987 , especially since Bird was three years older than Magic.
I understand that it’s all speculation and while I think Magic was better , I can understand how you could say Bird was , especially living in Boston. But the bottom line, including college and pro, they met in 4 championship finals, Magic won three. And for his career( college & pro), Magic won 6 championships, while Bird won three.
Thank you Jack of Spades
InternetKing, why mention Len Bias in a Magic/Bird story? they didn’t mention Kupchak.
I don’t think magic embarassed himself as a coach any more than Bird has embaraased himself as a Gm. And he made one comeback, not multiple.
Connie,
By “multiple” comebacks I was also counting the year he signed a contract and played the preseason but quit before the regular season after Karl Malone and some other guys bitched about it. Kind of a technicality.
Also Bias warranted mentioning (I thought) because he was supposed to take the pressure off Bird and keep his minutes down which could have kept the rivalry going a few years longer.
UB, you read the bird magic book? …. that story of the fan at the airport is in there, so cant hate on just HBO for that
Then why not mention Kupchak too then? He was a big acquistion and if not for his injury, he would have been a huge upgrade over Kurt rambis.
Those Boston racists… just a coincidence that the white guy turned out to be a quiet family man and the black guy banged every chick he could and caught AIDS.
A quiet family man who fathered a child he never acknowledged.And who also beat up somone in a Fanueuil hall bar room brawl.
And Jermaine, what does that have to do with anything anyway.
Bobby Orr was the most talented player I’ve ever seen play in Boston, followed by Bird and then Tom Brady. (I would have loved to have seen Russell.) These are they guys that you wanted (want in Brady’s case) in control of the game when all of the chips were on the line! That’s my definition of Greatness! Screw the popularity contests. These guys are all Great because they knew how to win, period. Magic was definitely in this Class. I think the point of the documentary was that despite their vast social differences, on the Court– they were basically the SAME player. (Check me if I’m wrong on that, Sandy!)
We all know Boston has a history of, and a problem with racism. I just have a problem when people make it seem like Boston had the market cornered on racism. It seems like people should worry about there own problems, but they bring up boston’s and hide their own.
As someone who has lived up and down the east coast, as a jew who doesn’t “look jewish,” and as a white man who typically dates outside of my race; I assure you that every area has a good amount of racists of all sizes and colors. Philly, for example, doesn’t have the rep; but they likely have the most racist police force north of the mason-dixon.
And American racism doesn’t even compare to Europe or Asia. Tokyo is still the most racist city i have ever lived in, and the only one where i heard racial slurs directed at someone every single day.
Pete , I agree with you 100%, but still, to try to pretend the Celtics of the 80s weren’t more appealing to white people because of the makeup of the team is just not true
Identifying with someone from your own race who succeeds is hardly racism. Or is it racist that Tiger Woods attracts young black kids to golf?
The Boston “racists” cheering on Bird, McHale and Ainge were also cheering on the Chief, DJ, and KC Jones, the black Hall of Fame Celtics player and head coach.
What do their personal lives have to do with anything? Not much, but they certainly don’t do much to dispell stereotypes either.
I have to admit, what pissed me off was watching the Celtics battle through tough teams in the eastern confernce and then face a well rested Lakers team that waltzed into the finals year after year after playing awful teams. They basically rested their starters for the finals and the Celtics would play multiple tough seven game series’ to get there.
[...] » 5 Mistakes HBO made in the Larry-Magic Special Boston.BarstoolSports.com [...]