Archie Manning Says the Colts Would be Stupid to Draft Andrew Luck
FoxSports – Back in 2004, Archie Manning actively tried to keep son Eli from being drafted by the then-hapless San Diego Chargers, who held the top overall pick… Sounds like Archie might again be dispensing advice regarding a No. 1 overall pick … though this time it’s directed to the Colts, longtime employers of one of Archie’s other sons, four-time MVP Peyton. Archie Manning was asked on FOXSports radio Tuesday if Indianapolis should draft Stanford QB Andrew Luck with the top pick next spring. “I don’t think it’d necessarily be great for either one,” he said regarding Peyton and Luck. “I think Andrew’s the type of mature player … he can walk right in (and play)…We know Andrew well. He comes down to our camp every year,” said Archie Manning, referring to the family’s offseason passing academy in Louisiana. He and Luck’s father, Oliver, were also teammates on the Houston Oilers in the 1980s. “Peyton’s always tried to help Andrew and kind of be a friend. (But) I doubt if either one of them want to play on the same team.”
With friends like these, who needs enemies, huh? Is there no end to the Manning family’s sense of entitlement? Archie in particular? The NFL created a monster with this guy when they caved into his demands in that ’04 draft. I mean, it’s one thing if he had Andrew Luck’s best interest at heart, came out and said he’d like to see things work out for the son of an old teammate. But this isn’t about that. This is 100% about him worried about someone younger and healthier coming along and taking his kid’s job. Not what’s best for Luck. And certainly not what’s best for the team that’s kissed Peyton and Archie’s asses all these years and made Peyton the richest player in the history of the NFL. Archie could give a rat’s taint if the Colts pass on a once-in-a-generation college QB only to find out Peyton is finished. He only cares about his own. He’s the geriatric version of a Pop Warner dad who thinks his kid should be the quarterback, the good of the team be damned. Look, it might or might not be the smart move for Indy to take Luck. But that’s their call to make. It’s not up to the doting father of their rapidly aging, possibly finished franchise player. If he is finished, I’m sure it will be hard for the Mannings to deal with, just like it was hard for the Culkins when Macauley got too old and they gave “Home Alone 3″ to Alex D. Linz. Or the Fannings when Dakota started losing all the “precocious waif” roles to Abigail Breslin. But sports parents like stage parents need to learn that even their precious little snowflake will get replaced eventually and there’s no use crying about it. Now I know where Peyton gets it from:
@JerryThornton1


Asshole changed his story already ….
http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/7327351/archie-manning-new-take-peyton-manning-andrew-luck-co-exist-indianapolis-colts
This is news? Really? Did you expect him to say “You know what, my kid sucks and his career is over. I think they should dump Peyton and grab the kid”? Its has dad LMAO obviously he’s a little biased. If you listen to the interview (instead of stealing news as is custom on BSS) you would know that both he and Peyton have very high praise for luck. Why the hell would you be supportive of someone taking your job though? I think I can say no one…no matter how bad they may be…is truly supportive of losing their job to a young kid that everyone is prematurely crowning as the 2012 NFL MVP.
a+
Jt you fucking idiot… He’s right. The team has no reason to sign Luck, because luck is leverage… The could regain their legacy status with one lucky transaction.
Asinine blog. He was right about both players.
The retraction is because he wants Peyton to get that 25 mm to be a “mentor”
Giraffe neck manning is fucking toast. I hope these cunts don’t draft luck
Nothing worse than overbearing parents, that said, he’s right, doesn’t make sense to have two top 10 qbs because its a misallocation of resources. This year showed us the team sucks, but if you plug peyton back in the offense is probably a top 5 or so unit, so they need to figure out if what they can get for the number one pick is sufficient to fix the defense or if their drafts have been so bad that they need to start over. In that case trade Peyton to a qb needy team with a good D, San Fran or the Jets, and start completely rebuilding around Luck with the goal of competing in 3 years. Doesn’t make sense to have both but that also doesn’t mean Peyton is the one they should keep.
hes worried about someone taking his sons job and source of income? fuckin prick he is lemme tell ya
you are a jackass what the fuck do you expect the guy to say? no please sign a guy who will put my son out of his job with the colts. backing up his son is showing a sense of entitlement? fuck off loser, get over your manning hate, get brady’s dick out of your mouth and stop embarrassing yourself.
The point is, why doesn’t Archie stay the fuck out of it? You don’t hear stories about Donovan McNabb’s mother taking time off from making soup commercials to lobby for her son to keep his starting job in Minnesota. It’s absolute bullshit, and ultimately it’s none of his business.
Fuck Archie Manning. I am a Chargers fan and that bullshit in 04 will make me forever hate Archie/Eli. Yes Eli has a Super Bowl, blah blah blah, but what person wouldn’t want to live in San Diego and make a bajillion dollars (and save the “NYC is more marketable).
Also, Peyton will count about 29mil or so against the cap in the coming years….I would rather cut Peyton and sign a 22 year old stud rather than a 30something injury prone dude (now with the neck thing). Peyton, bar far is one of the top 3 QBs of my generation, but just as players say who move to other teams, “its a business” and you don’t pass on an Andrew Luck….unless you can get a Herchel Walker/Ricky Williams type trade for the pick
Are you kidding me here Thornton? Get a real job you fucking smut peddling puts. I suppose you think Tom Brady’s dad wouldn’t defend his son if asked the same question. NEWS FLASH FUCK FACE: Every single Father from pro-athletes to fucking Iron Workers are going to defend and support their SON. YOU FUCKING IDIOT. Jesus Christ Waste of a blog. Go write something that is fucking note worthy you fucking shit head Jesus Christ I hate you.
cford beat me too it. but i’d like to add that is the most shank-iest article you have ever written Jerome, you raper of children.
you write articles that you know are fundamentally flawed just to see peoples reaction just like Shank. zero difference. i know you are just a blogger but take some pride in your work and try not to be such a blatant hypocrite. you wonder why people hate your writing this article is it.
@cantgetthestinkout – first off cool name. second, he was asked about it idiot he didn’t volunteer, he was asked about it, its getting press clearly, so he retracted his statement already to ESPN. He didn’t just take a podeum and say ” THE COLTS SHOULDN’T DRAFT LUCK.” He was asked about his son and the idea that Luck would sit behind him and all he basically said was that Luck is too good to sit behind anyone. If anything he complimented him. Stupid.
Jerry Thornton is the worst.
Hey k1dd0 you misspelled “Putz” in your first comment. Stupid.
Archie shouldn’t have been lobbying for his 22 year old full grown man of a son to play in a certain city when Eli came into the league. Peyton is a 35 year old man. His daddy is attempting to use his influence to sway the decision of the Indianapolis Colts so his son can keep his starting job. Of course he’s gonna sugar coat it by complimenting Luck. Get your head out of your ass.
A 34 or 35 year old QB only has a few years left in them…look at Favre. A QB needs a few years to be grommed…look at Rodgers. Archie is stupid. In three years a 38 year old Manning and an Andrew Luck with a few years on the bench would be perfect for the Colts if they can afford it.
They should go after Luck and use Manning to work w/ him and develop his skills over the next 2 years then Luck should be good to start. I don’t care HOW GOOD he is, saying he can waltz into the NFL and just start is a bold fucking statement by the ESPN Luck nutswingers…every year they deem whether or not a QB can just start from day 1 for an NFL team, now…sure maybe Luck COULD start right away and be OK, hell maybe he’d be successful like Newton, but more than likely he’d be a better QB overall if he mentored for a couple years under an experienced pedigreed QB like Manning – couldn’t be a better scenario for the team or Luck…it just sucks for Peyton because even if he does start next year it’ll signify the beginning of the end for him and his daddy knows it too.
Eli Manning>Phillip Rivers
it’s not even a debate anymore
Outside of sucking Fillachick’s cock Jerry Thornton is a fucking worthless homer piece of shit. Hey idiot, did you think to consider that maybe he was actually praising Luck by saying he’s ready to come in and start? Not to mention the Colts can easily trade Manning if he’s healthy again. Regardless your commentary on Manning’s comments are pathetic to say the least. Standard Jerry.
5minutemajor has it right. all you idiots saying the Colts shouldnt get both QBs on their team are retarded. this is a QB driven league more than ever before. You think Green Bay is happy they had a 1st round guy sit for a few seasons behind a HOFer so he was ready to step in when Favre retired (kind of)? if you dont have an elite QB you can kiss any ounce of hope of ever getting a Lombardi trophy fucking goodbye. Unless you are the 2000 Ravens, which the league rules simply wont allow for anymore then you need an elite QB, simple as that. if you have a guy with a career threatening injury in his mid-30s and you have the opportunity to get a guy who every NFL analyst has been blowing for the last 2 or 3 years you do it….unless youre cool being the Miami Dolphins for the next 15 years…..
They 100% should draft Luck and have him learn from Peyton. Anyone saying otherwise is retarded, including Archie. I’ve heard the counter argument is that Luck can just walk in and start and won’t be happy and that Peyton won’t be happy to have Luck waiting in the wings but, guess what, most of the time if the option pisses off both people its probably the right choice.
If you are the Colts you absolutely take Luck #1 or you trade him for a 2012 round 1 and a 2013 round 1 and see if anyone bites. I mean, Luck is good, but if this year proved anything its that they need a lot more than a QB to get back to where they were.
They 100% should draft Luck and have him learn from Peyton. Anyone saying otherwise is retarded, including Archie. I’ve heard the counter argument is that Luck can just walk in and start and won’t be happy and that Peyton won’t be happy to have Luck waiting in the wings but, guess what, most of the time if the option pisses off both people its probably the right choice.If you are the Colts you absolutely take Luck #1 or you trade him for a 2012 round 1 and a 2013 round 1 and see if anyone bites. I mean, Luck is good, but if this year proved anything its that they need a lot more than a QB to get back to where they were.
All Archie said was that he thinks Luck is an NFL ready QB and that it would be stupid to have both QB’s on the same team. More of a compliment to Luck if you ask me Way to read into everything way too much. Comparing Archie to Mcnabbs mom = fail. Archie was an NFL player lots of former players call in to radio shows and give quotes ala Joe Namath.
Why are you so obsessed with Peyton Manning Jerry? Afraid he is better than Brady?
Seems like he was asked his opinion on the matter, doesn’t seem like it came unsolicited. And what’s wrong with a father’s position. Archie apparently changed his mind, or reconsidered his previous response, and was humble enough to correct himself. Also, what’s with the insinuations that Manning sucks. Maybe he’s looking at the end of his career, and you can hate on him if you want to suck Big Tom’s dick, but to say anything less than he’s had a stellar career shows someone that doesn’t appreciate the sport. Truth is, although hard to admit, Manning may not have the rings that Brady and the Pats do, but the mother fucker is debatably the best damn quarterback to play the game. I have to respect Manning, and he seems like a good-natured person. Fact is, if he heals up well, and optimistically gets three more seasons under his belt he’s gonna own the bulk of QB records. Manning might be the antagonist for my Pats, but I make no bones in recognizing his amazing talent. It’s a love-hate kinda thing. And Pats-Colts games are always the best. IMHO.
Was it just Archie’s opinion that Eli should play in NY instead of San Diego? No, he made it happen. Did he take to a podium and announce to the entire world that he would see to it that his son played in New York and not for a then slap dick team like San Diego? No, he’s a little smarter than that. And how many times have fans in New York bitched on this blog when Joe Namath throws his two cents in regarding Sanchez or the Jets? ”Shut up old man. No one gives a shit what you have to say. You’re out of touch. Blah blah blah.” But I guess it’s okay for Archie to do it.
so Hit Girl was a precocious waif? Interesting.