I Can’t Believe I’m Dignifying Shank’s Hatchet Job On Nomar With A Response

Boston.com - Total fraud. I hate to be the fly in the punch bowl here, but yesterday’s lovefest involving Nomar Garciaparra and the Red Sox was truly nauseating. If Nomar had been hooked up to a polygraph, the machine would have exploded. Truly unbelievable. There was Nomar, seated between Larry Lucchino and Theo Epstein, telling us how much he always loved the Red Sox, how much he loved the Nation. “We needed to talk about how unhappy Nomar was,’’ Lucchino recalled in December of ’04. “Was there anything that could be done to change his mental state of mind, his approach to the organization, the city, and the game? We basically concluded that there was no way we were going to have a happy Nomar Garciaparra for the last couple of months of the season.’’ So Epstein made the deal, sending Garciaparra to the Cubs a week later. And then the Red Sox turned things around and won the World Series. Off the field, he did charity work, kept his mouth shut, and interacted well with fans. He was one of the three great shortstops of his era, alongside Alex Rodriguez and Jeter. In good times and bad, Garciaparra was unnecessarily difficult in all interactions with the media. Garciaparra is the one who had a red stripe put down in front of lockers in the Sox clubhouse. Woe was the scribe who crossed Nomar’s line of death.
Everybody is sending me this article from Shank today. I didn’t feel like I had to talk about it since what I wrote yesterday pretty much corroborates everything Shank wrote today. But whatever, I’ll get Shank’s dick hard and talk about him for a couple seconds. Like I said this article pretty much sums up exactly why I love him and why everybody should love him, but Shank is just too stupid to even realize he made my case for me. From Shank;
“Off the field, he did charity work, kept his mouth shut, and interacted well with fans. He was one of the three great shortstops of his era, alongside Alex Rodriguez and Jeter.”
Don’t forget he never took a play off, an at bat off or an inning off.
But yet Shank still hated him and thinks he is a fraud. Why? Well let Shank tell you himself.
“In good times and bad, Garciaparra was unnecessarily difficult in all interactions with the media. Garciaparra is the one who had a red stripe put down in front of lockers in the Sox clubhouse. Woe was the scribe who crossed Nomar’s line of death.”
So basically playing hard, keeping your mouth shut, being good with fans but hating the media makes you a fraud. Okay….And my favorite part is how he threw in a One Eyed Bandit quote for good measure. That’s what I was talking about with the Smear Campaign after he left. The new ownership was so petrified of public bash lash they just made shit up about him and leaked it to the press. And as I said on The Power Hour the way Lucchino smashed Nomar after his departure was the beginning of the divide between Theo and Larry.
Essentially the only thing Shank got right in this article is that Nomar was pretending to get along with the One Eyed Bandit yesterday. I’m sure he hates his guts and rightfully so. I’m also pretty sure it wasn’t Nomar’s idea to sit next to him at the press conference and pretend they were best buds. If he wanted to retire a Red Sox where he had his best years and show how much he loved the fans he had no choice.
Bottom line is this when deciding who is right about Nomar. I don’t know Nomar. Never met him. Just watched him play. Fell in love with his style, appreciation of the game and the way he treated the fans of this city. Shank couldn’t get an interview with so he has a vendetta and hates his guts. Who you going to believe is giving a fair representation?
PS – I honestly can’t believe I just dignified this garbage with a blog.
Well said Pres. Shaughnessy is so out of touch with the sports worl. I think he actually believes he is on the same level of the players he covers.
“I don’t know Nomar. Never met him. Just watched him play.”
They way you talk about him, i would have swore you went out for beers and shit with him all the time
I’m pretty sure he took July 1st 2004 off.
Meter was spewing the same BS today on EEI.
pretty sure none of your blogs would be defined as ‘dignified’
but youre on the money, shanks the fraud here, and he spells out his own failures as a journalist in plain english
Sorry, you are in the minority…..The JOKE is them coming back with this stupid publicity stunt…..
No thanks…..You were on our team…great ….and then we didnt want (or need—see 2 rings) you anymore
I know I am probably giving Shank and the rest of the Nomar haters too much credit, but…. I dont think the point is Nomar is a fraud.
Nomar was one of the greatest Sox players ever, but towards the end of his time here it seemed like he had enough of Boston. The new management clearly led a smear campaign against him once he was gone.
With all of that said, it just seemed a bit dopey having Lucchino and Theo throwing Nomar this love fest yesterday, that seems to be a fraud.
Hey Dave –
Get off Nomar’s dick. You don’t know the guy. Like you’ve said, you’ve never met him. You’ve never spoken to him. How the fuck do you really know if he was a good guy or not. You can’t. Shaughnessy met him, knew him, covered him. For as long as he was in Boston. The general consensus on Nomar is he didn’t treat the media well. You’re part of the media as far as I’m concerned; you write, you critique, you publicly criticize. Ipso facto, he would’ve treated you like shit as well.
I was never as big a fan of Nomar as everyone else, but I always respected the way he played and what he meant to the city when he was here. That said, Pres, you couldn’t have laid it out any better. Shank is a joke who is just spewing semen-scented garbage from his mouth just so he still has a job. The ovation last year speaks for itself, Boston loves Nomar. Shank doesn’t get that kind of affection when he gets home from work.
Nino, he is blatantly calling Nomar a fraud. How else do you translate this?
“If Nomar had been hooked up to a polygraph, the machine would have exploded.”
El Pres – dont cut and paste the story to make it sound like a bash job, just read the article:
Take this portion:
In good times and bad, Garciaparra was unnecessarily difficult in all interactions with the media. It made no sense, given the fawning coverage he received (and deserved) for the first seven years of his career. Fans needn’t care which players give good sound bites, but no one was more unhappy than Nomar, and it infected the workplace.
It’s forgiving of the Sox to bring him back, but there’s no need to reinvent history in the process. Sox fans are too smart. It’s insulting for Epstein, Lucchino, and Garciaparra to insist that this relationship has always been good.
What said here is false?
Trinity
A fraud for playing along with this charade yesterday, not as a player. He rattles off Nomar’s awesome stats for seven years
“A case can be made that he was Boston’s best home-grown player since Carl Yastrzemski. He played eight seasons with the Sox. He finished second in MVP voting in 1998. He hit .357 and .372 in back-to-back seasons, which made him one of the American League’s best righthanded hitters since Joe DiMaggio. He was Hall of Fame-bound and a legitimate Fenway god.”
It is a bit much to see Nomar profess that he always had love for Boston, by the end of 2004, that wasn’t the case. I am sure he loved the fans, but the media and new management never mixed well for Nomar.
For the record, I consider Nomar one the greatest Sox players, but he had some tough times here.
nino,
I don’t know how what you wrote changed anything I said? Nomar didn’t choose to sit up there with those guys.
Nomar is a soccer playing pansy.
El Pres – that is a solid point, I forgot Lucchino and Theo probably told Nomar they would be joining him on stage 10 seconds before they want on.
End of the day, Nomar was one of the best, and I am glad that he will be retired as a Sox player. Yesterday was a circus, and most of that probably occurred because of Sox management.
I know Shank usually brings a cynical view to things, I just dont think what he said about yesterday was totally off.
Honestly, just when you think Shank can’t get any worse, he finds a new bottom (gay inference intended). Can someone please tell me how this guy still has a job?
Shank is a loser with a axe to grind. What’s wrong Shank did Nomah hurt your feelings? Do you think anybody in this town cares that Nomar didn’t give you and your cronies such as Buckley the time of day? The guy was incredible between the lines where it counts and who gives a shit if he made it hard for you to do your job grow up you little baby.
” I didn’t feel like I had to talk about it since what I wrote yesterday pretty much corroborates everything Shank wrote today.”
corroborates:(def.) to strengthen or support with other evidence.
So what you said yesterday validates Shank’s points, huh?
C’mon Wolverine!
I’ve been boycotting Shank since ’05 and life’s been a lot better. I advise all to do the same.
Pres just pwned the shit out of CHB.
And steroids? What about steroids??
EP:
“PS – I honestly can’t believe I just dignified this garbage with a blog.”…
are you serious….you can’t help yourself when it comes to Globe and Simmons…..serious penis envy I think
Shank was on the sports hub today. If you think he’s an obnoxious douche in print just listen to him on the radio. Please go away CHB!!
“but hating the media makes you a fraud”..
yeah, when now you are working for them…