This is a fucking travesty, but i hate to say it, that in no way shape or form will he be awarded the perfect game..
Fuck that ump and his handle bar mustache
If he ever umps another game is just a total disgrace to baseball. Baseball is not like the NBA where something like this accepted to get another couple game out of a conference final.
Utter bullshit. we were all robbed of history being made tonight. i was watchin’ w/ my bro and jim joyce fucked up a great moment. what a piece of shit.
Major League Baseball has to overturn that call. That CLEARLY was the last out of the game. they are fucking dirtbags if they don’t man up and fix this.
Just fucking replay everything. It’s pretty shitty when in 2010 I can see from my couch that the wrong call was made but some barrel ass geriatric umpire can’t or won’t.
Don Deckinger and now Jim Joyce will forever be linked to the two WORST calls in MLB HISTORY!!!
I hope you two like living out your days in misery….you fucking TOOLS!
Major League Baseball has to overturn that call. That CLEARLY was the last out of the game. they are fucking dirtbags if they don’t man up and fix this.
Love to see them do this, the umpires would go ballistic though.. and I doubt we’ll hear anything much from Joyce except the standard response.
Can the official scorekeeper change that play to an error than? Doesn’t make up for the lost perfect game, but at least the guy would have a no-hitter…..and a big F-U to Jim Joyce…???
They shouldn’t overturn it, it kind of cheapens the perfect game in a way. What happened, happened and that is all you can really say. The ump fucked up.
If I were Joyce I would honestly be fearing for my life right now. It’s fucking Detroit, one of the toughest cities in America. This dude needs some serious security EVERYWHERE he goes.
Anybody who thinks that call should be overturned is a fucking moron. The wrong call was made, but a shitload of wrong calls have been made and are all of those going to be overturned as well?
You cant protest this game and get a perfect game from it, and Joyce will be back on the field tomorrow night nothing will come of this just another blown call and more proof that something needs to change
if MLB had Replay we would have had a 3rd perfect game of this season All these perfect games would not be happening either if we just let players take steroids
I have never been a huge fan of complete instant replay, but sometimes it takes drastic things to help ppl make up their minds. This blown call definitely made up my mind. I’ve had enough of all the fuckups. Get instant replay in baseball NOW!
You’re a bigger cunt than Jim Joyce for writing that. It makes no sense. He’s not young. It’s not remotely clever or funny. Congrats on finishing a book you fucking pretentious queefe.
The ump isn’t a douche. He messed up, like everyone does. He admitted that he did and he owned up to it. There’s not much else he can do. He also apologized to Galarraga’s face after the game and is willing to take on all of the criticism.
jim joyce…absolute jackass, and the number 9 hitters an asshole for running it out…jog down the line like manny, your a number 9 hitter you ass, youre in there for fielding purposes only
1. Det. Will protest and win thus getting credit for the perfect game.
you cant protest a judgement call first of all. Secondly, theyre not going to overturn it for a perfect game if they didnt overturn a similar play in the 1985 world series that cost the Cardinals a championship.
worse than steroids. worse than a-rods existence. people are gonna give joyce sympathy but he wouldnt need it if he didnt give the benefit to the runner with 2 outs in the 9th with a perfect game. just tragic.
» Spictor Martinez said: { Jun 2, 2010 – 10:06:08 }
jim joyce…absolute jackass, and the number 9 hitters an asshole for running it out…jog down the line like manny, your a number 9 hitter you ass, youre in there for fielding purposes only
Only reason I say now is if it were me throwing a perfect game, I wouldn’t want it given to me.
Something like that you have to earn.
All 27
Also, as much as it would suck to be the ump at this point
at least he’s admitted he was wrong and is cutting himself down for making that bad of a mistake
Jim Joyce was the ump that called Mark Bellhorn’s home run a double in game 6 of the 2004 ALCS. The umps got together and reversed the call-just like they reversed the call later in that game when A-Rod bitchslapped the ball out of Bronson Arroyo’s glove. Have umpires ever gotten together since to reverse calls? Should have happened tonight, if ever. Replay should be instituted tonight.
Jim Joyce is such a fucking piece of dogshit. To make a call like that and ruin a hi-light of a dudes career… on such a blown call, it just straight up sucks so bad.
It sucks for all involved but the game favors human calls over reply. Humans make mistakes, we all agree. Doesn’t make the ump an asshole by any means. We all make mistakes. The timing of this mistake was especially wicked. I wonder if it would have been worse if there hadn’t been another (two) perfect game in ten years?
Mistake or not, this brings up a topic in sports that needs addressing: Why are referees in the major pro sports so bad at their job, yet protected so much? Everyone should know by now these ‘referees’ are just incompetent wannabe’s. In the NBA, not one ref played in the league, they are all short and/or bald guys who is on their own program. In the NFL, they are old, fat and need replay to fix every call. In the NHL, they are failed hockey players who know how to skate, but who also is also on their own agenda. You can get a consistant call game after game. And lastly, their is MLB. The easiest of them all. Umpires. They have to stand there and get 2-3 plays right a game. They are old, fat, and have the biggest egos known to man. No wonder they all drop of heartattacks. Mistake or not, when someone f**ks up this bad, they need to be fired like any other job. I’m just glad it happened so that finally people can give some fair critizism of these bozos. The bottom line is, none of them are held accountable.
Congratulations on being an illiterate hillbilly, you briar hopping grit. Go clean out the hood scoop on your trans camaro and leave the posting to the adults.
I’ll make a deal with you: I won’t tell you how to suck dicks if you don’t tell me how to make literary references.
I hope all you fucktards that complain about how baseball games are too long take notice of shit like this. It’s more important to get the calls right than making sure you get the full 9 hours of sleep you need to function in the AM cuz you’re such pussies. You can always catch the highlights the next AM anyway. Dennis and Callahan, you whiny fucks, I’m looking in your direction.
Eric Cartman–You know who reversed the call on Bellhorn’s HR in game 6? that would be none other than the douchiest douche to ever ump a ML game, Joe West.
JimCarr – They’re called “unions”. It’s that simple. Players unions fight for no drug testing and ridiculous salaries; umpires unions fight for what comes down to essentially tenure.
by True Heart Good Peoples on June 3, 2010 at 9:46 am
» Spork said: { Jun 2, 2010 – 10:06:04 }
Portrait of the Umpire as a Young Douchebag.
———–
You’re a bigger cunt than Jim Joyce for writing that. It makes no sense. He’s not young. It’s not remotely clever or funny. Congrats on finishing a book you fucking pretentious queefe.
Spork, you ignorant slut. The James Joyce association was clever. Hilarious? Not really. Worth of a “cunt” toss? Certainly not. Also, it’s “queef.” Now pick up your mop and get back to work.
Instead of overturning the call, the MLB could begin using instant replay and admit Gallaraga’s performance was the reason. even though you aren’t the 21st person to throw a perfect game, you’re at least known as the guy who ignited instant replay.
Yea…about that. Just another ump trying to get his name in the papers.
Worst. Call. Ever.
just another day in detroit
Tigers announcers sounded like somebody neutered them. Jim Joyce fucking sucks.
I just reversed my stance on replay if an official calls for one.
I don’t know if there’s a precedent, but MLB has to change this tomorrow and credit him with a perfect game.
Sort of tough for all those “human error is part of the game” people to defend themselves right about now
impossible. No way that just happened. what an asshole
This is a fucking travesty, but i hate to say it, that in no way shape or form will he be awarded the perfect game..
Fuck that ump and his handle bar mustache
ew.
ew ew ewwwwww.
painful to watch
should have been 3 perfect games in a month’s span, ridiculous.
If he ever umps another game is just a total disgrace to baseball. Baseball is not like the NBA where something like this accepted to get another couple game out of a conference final.
Utter bullshit. we were all robbed of history being made tonight. i was watchin’ w/ my bro and jim joyce fucked up a great moment. what a piece of shit.
I felt horrible for this kid, god damn.
Major League Baseball has to overturn that call. That CLEARLY was the last out of the game. they are fucking dirtbags if they don’t man up and fix this.
Just fucking replay everything. It’s pretty shitty when in 2010 I can see from my couch that the wrong call was made but some barrel ass geriatric umpire can’t or won’t.
Don Deckinger and now Jim Joyce will forever be linked to the two WORST calls in MLB HISTORY!!!
I hope you two like living out your days in misery….you fucking TOOLS!
Major League Baseball has to overturn that call. That CLEARLY was the last out of the game. they are fucking dirtbags if they don’t man up and fix this.
Love to see them do this, the umpires would go ballistic though.. and I doubt we’ll hear anything much from Joyce except the standard response.
over/under 4 years before galaraga is found to have a ray finkle-esque hate-shrine of joyce in his bedroom.
Can the official scorekeeper change that play to an error than? Doesn’t make up for the lost perfect game, but at least the guy would have a no-hitter…..and a big F-U to Jim Joyce…???
Jim Joyce should do the right thing and kill himself tonight.
Technically they can overturn the call and make it an error thus giving him a no-hitter. But a prefect game, that is long gone.
They shouldn’t overturn it, it kind of cheapens the perfect game in a way. What happened, happened and that is all you can really say. The ump fucked up.
I’m fucking sick to my stomache. The pitcher was the nicest guy, too.
Kudos to galarraga for keeping his cool. That said, I wouldn’t have minded it if cabrera ripped out joyce’s heart right then and there.
Typical cunt umpire call. It’s a goddamn shame that happened.
If I were Joyce I would honestly be fearing for my life right now. It’s fucking Detroit, one of the toughest cities in America. This dude needs some serious security EVERYWHERE he goes.
Portrait of the Umpire as a Young Douchebag.
Anybody who thinks that call should be overturned is a fucking moron. The wrong call was made, but a shitload of wrong calls have been made and are all of those going to be overturned as well?
1. Det. Will protest and win thus getting credit for the perfect game.
2. You can’t throw a historic surprise party 14 hours after the honoree knew it happened.
Good riddens to that ump, u won’t see him for a while
A james joyce reference on barstool? I’m going to pass out.
You cant protest this game and get a perfect game from it, and Joyce will be back on the field tomorrow night nothing will come of this just another blown call and more proof that something needs to change
if MLB had Replay we would have had a 3rd perfect game of this season All these perfect games would not be happening either if we just let players take steroids
I have never been a huge fan of complete instant replay, but sometimes it takes drastic things to help ppl make up their minds. This blown call definitely made up my mind. I’ve had enough of all the fuckups. Get instant replay in baseball NOW!
Portrait of the Umpire as a Young Douchebag.
———–
You’re a bigger cunt than Jim Joyce for writing that. It makes no sense. He’s not young. It’s not remotely clever or funny. Congrats on finishing a book you fucking pretentious queefe.
RESIGN M F’er BULLSHIT CALL!
The ump isn’t a douche. He messed up, like everyone does. He admitted that he did and he owned up to it. There’s not much else he can do. He also apologized to Galarraga’s face after the game and is willing to take on all of the criticism.
jim joyce…absolute jackass, and the number 9 hitters an asshole for running it out…jog down the line like manny, your a number 9 hitter you ass, youre in there for fielding purposes only
» southie said: { Jun 2, 2010 – 09:06:08 }
1. Det. Will protest and win thus getting credit for the perfect game.
you cant protest a judgement call first of all. Secondly, theyre not going to overturn it for a perfect game if they didnt overturn a similar play in the 1985 world series that cost the Cardinals a championship.
That’s as fucked up as it gets.
The ump should be ashamed
worse than steroids. worse than a-rods existence. people are gonna give joyce sympathy but he wouldnt need it if he didnt give the benefit to the runner with 2 outs in the 9th with a perfect game. just tragic.
» Spictor Martinez said: { Jun 2, 2010 – 10:06:08 }
jim joyce…absolute jackass, and the number 9 hitters an asshole for running it out…jog down the line like manny, your a number 9 hitter you ass, youre in there for fielding purposes only
Only reason I say now is if it were me throwing a perfect game, I wouldn’t want it given to me.
Something like that you have to earn.
All 27
Also, as much as it would suck to be the ump at this point
at least he’s admitted he was wrong and is cutting himself down for making that bad of a mistake
http://www.detnews.com/article/20100602/SPORTS0104/6020433/1265/Umpire-admits-he-cost-Tigers–Galarraga-perfect-game
Bag Job! I didn’t know Tim Donaghy worked for the MLB?
Spork, thank you.
Football, once again, letting other sports shoot themselves in the foot. NFL! USA! NFL! USA!
Did some asshole here say the call is worse than steroids?
Jim Joyce was the ump that called Mark Bellhorn’s home run a double in game 6 of the 2004 ALCS. The umps got together and reversed the call-just like they reversed the call later in that game when A-Rod bitchslapped the ball out of Bronson Arroyo’s glove. Have umpires ever gotten together since to reverse calls? Should have happened tonight, if ever. Replay should be instituted tonight.
Galarraga just made me dislike latino baseball a little less, he was very classy.
Jim Joyce is such a fucking piece of dogshit. To make a call like that and ruin a hi-light of a dudes career… on such a blown call, it just straight up sucks so bad.
It sucks for all involved but the game favors human calls over reply. Humans make mistakes, we all agree. Doesn’t make the ump an asshole by any means. We all make mistakes. The timing of this mistake was especially wicked. I wonder if it would have been worse if there hadn’t been another (two) perfect game in ten years?
Jim Joyce just called a techincal foul on Kendrick Perkins
wayne jetski lmao… And congrats on the great career jr.
Mistake or not, this brings up a topic in sports that needs addressing: Why are referees in the major pro sports so bad at their job, yet protected so much? Everyone should know by now these ‘referees’ are just incompetent wannabe’s. In the NBA, not one ref played in the league, they are all short and/or bald guys who is on their own program. In the NFL, they are old, fat and need replay to fix every call. In the NHL, they are failed hockey players who know how to skate, but who also is also on their own agenda. You can get a consistant call game after game. And lastly, their is MLB. The easiest of them all. Umpires. They have to stand there and get 2-3 plays right a game. They are old, fat, and have the biggest egos known to man. No wonder they all drop of heartattacks. Mistake or not, when someone f**ks up this bad, they need to be fired like any other job. I’m just glad it happened so that finally people can give some fair critizism of these bozos. The bottom line is, none of them are held accountable.
Spork,
Congratulations on being an illiterate hillbilly, you briar hopping grit. Go clean out the hood scoop on your trans camaro and leave the posting to the adults.
I’ll make a deal with you: I won’t tell you how to suck dicks if you don’t tell me how to make literary references.
I hope all you fucktards that complain about how baseball games are too long take notice of shit like this. It’s more important to get the calls right than making sure you get the full 9 hours of sleep you need to function in the AM cuz you’re such pussies. You can always catch the highlights the next AM anyway. Dennis and Callahan, you whiny fucks, I’m looking in your direction.
Eric Cartman–You know who reversed the call on Bellhorn’s HR in game 6? that would be none other than the douchiest douche to ever ump a ML game, Joe West.
David Stern must have called in the fix.
Deke Zucker = pony tail guy in Good Will Hunting
Relax dude. Spork was right, your original comment wasn’t funny.
JimCarr – They’re called “unions”. It’s that simple. Players unions fight for no drug testing and ridiculous salaries; umpires unions fight for what comes down to essentially tenure.
hahahahahahaha detroit sux
Kudos to Joyce for copping to it. Too often when people screw up they don’t admit it and will lie their asses off to the bitter end.
Joyce, ” I just cost that kid a perfect game”
Bravo sir!
» Spork said: { Jun 2, 2010 – 10:06:04 }
Portrait of the Umpire as a Young Douchebag.
———–
You’re a bigger cunt than Jim Joyce for writing that. It makes no sense. He’s not young. It’s not remotely clever or funny. Congrats on finishing a book you fucking pretentious queefe.
Spork, you ignorant slut. The James Joyce association was clever. Hilarious? Not really. Worth of a “cunt” toss? Certainly not. Also, it’s “queef.” Now pick up your mop and get back to work.
michael scarn…Yeah, i remembered it was Joe West that reversed those calls in game 6 of the ALCS
Instead of overturning the call, the MLB could begin using instant replay and admit Gallaraga’s performance was the reason. even though you aren’t the 21st person to throw a perfect game, you’re at least known as the guy who ignited instant replay.
One of the worst calls I’ve ever seen. Sucks to be you, Detroit.
http://cuzscorner.wordpress.com/2010/06/03/hey-jim-joyce-stay-hot/
Gallaraga’s main feat is overlooked here. Fucking 88 pitches!?!? Are you kidding me!? You mean you made baseball watchable!?!?
And this is how the league pays you back!?!?
Funniest thing is Jason Donald’s reaction. He’s as horrified by the call as Gallaraga….maybe even more horrified.