Nomar and the All Time Irreplaceable List
One of the wisest sayings ever uttered is “the cemeteries are full of indispensable people.” The point being that everyone needs to get over themselves. The guy at your office who thinks no one can function without him, ought to realize that if he gets hit by lighting on the way home tonight, you’re open for business the next day. Everyone is replaceable. Well not everyone. Sometimes, under very rare circumstances, you come across someone you just can’t find a substitute for. Someone who casts such a long shadow that long after they’ve moved on, you’re still looking for a replacement and everyone you throw in there fails to live up to the lofty standards that guy set.
In Boston that guy is Nomar Garciaparra. It occurred to me while watching Julio Lugo and Nick Green, game after game, failing to get to the tough balls and booting the easy ones, that we’re now two months shy of five years since the Sox traded Nomar and the club still hasn’t found an adequate, permanent replacement for him. They’ve made trades, brought guys up from AAA, brought in journeyman veterans and thrown tons of money at the problem, but they still haven’t solved it. A team whose minor league system is the envy of baseball can’t solve this one position to the point where the shortstop hole is a Black Hole, drawing everything into its giant void of suckiness. The post-Nomar Sox shortstop list is a series of guys they misfired on, discarded for whatever reason, or who were just plain Bum of the Month Club members: Orlando Cabrera, Alex Cora, Rickey Gutierrez, Alex Gonzalez, Edgar Renteria and Jed Lowrie are just a few of the guys who have tried and failed to hold onto the bar that Nomar set so high. And there’s no one coming along in the minors so it looks like it will continue. And if lifetime spent wasting my time making stupid lists has taught me anything, some guys you can just never replace. The All Irreplaceable List:
Augustus
The first Roman Emperor. He took power after the assassination of Julius Caesar, gave himself absolute rule over the Republic and turned it into an Empire. In his 41 years on the throne, he expanded Rome from Northern Spain to the Alps to Southern Egypt, the Pax Romana. Widely beloved by his people, celebrated by the poet Virgil as the defender of Rome and the upholder of moral justice, Augustus left an impossibly big pair of sandals to fill (that messy business of killing Jesus aside). He was succeeded by Tiberius, Claudius, Caligula, Nero, Galba, Otho and half a millenium more of one stiff after another. It’s a pretty sorry legacy when all you’ve got to show for centuries of rulers is Capt. Kirk’s middle name and a cheesy porn movie.
John ‘Stumpy’ Pepys
The original drummer of The Thamesmen, later became “Spinal Tap.” Pepys died in a bizarre gardening accident after the release of the band’s album “Silent But Deadly” Authorities would later say Pepys death was “better left unsolved.” In his aftermath, the band had a series of drummers, all of whom died under mysterious circumstances. Stumpy Joe Childs who choked on vomit (someone else’s), Peter Bond who died of Spontaneous Human Combustion (leaving only a green globule on his drum stool) and Mick Shrimpton who exploded on stage.
Robert E. Lee
Lee was Lincoln’s first choice to be the Commander of the Union Army, but chose instead to lead the Confederates which for Lincoln was akin to how the NY Jets felt when Bill Belichick went to the Patriots. And as with the Jets, there was a hell of a drop off between Plan A and Plan B. The Old Railsplitter went through Winfield Scott, George McClelland and Henry Hallack without finding one who’d come out of his goddamned tent and kick some rebel ass. He finally settled on Ulysses S. Grant, a world class drunk and a half the general Lee was. Only massive superiority in the North’s troop strength won the war.
Bobby Layne
The last great… OK, the only great… Detroit Lions quarterback. Over a ten year span he led Detroit to 3 NFL Championships and made himself a lock for the Hall of Fame. So the team, in the first of a half a century of gawdawful decisions, traded him to Pittburgh in 1958. Supposedly upon hearing of the trade Layne said the Lions wouldn’t win for 50 years, and Year 50 of the Curse of Bobby Layne, 2008, yielded an 0-16 record. Between Layne and No. 1 draft pick Matthew Stafford Detroit has lined up such legendary QB’s as Greg Landry, Eric Hipple, Gary Danielson and the immortal Joey Harrington, a Detroit fail so epic even Washington couldn’t bail it out.
Freddy Mercury
Mercury died in 1991. The fact that Queen is still performing today is more a testament to him than anyone they brought in to fill his spandex. Wyclef Jean, George Michael, Elton John, Paul Rogers have all sung lead with the band at one time or another with only occasional, minimal success on the charts. The void Mercury left is so big 18 years later, that the band has openly discussed American Idol runner up and El Presidente mancrush Adam Lambert as the only man talented enough to take his place.
Howard Cosell
He might have been an obnoxious gasbag, a shameless shill for the New York teams and hung on to the job way too long, but 25 years after Cosell left the booth they’re still looking for someone to take his place. The unsuccessful attempts include Dan Dierdorf, Joe Namath, OJ Simpson, Boomer Esiason, Dennis Miller and Tony Kornheiser. It speaks volumes that Cosell’s most popular replacement murdered two people.
Will Ferrell as George W. Bush
Ferrell did Bush on SNL from 1999-2002 and since he left every Caucasian male in the cast has taken a run at it. Darrell Hammond, Chris Parnell, Will Forte and now someone named Jason Sudeikis have all been pale comparisons. While Frank Caliendo weeps that W. is gone, SNL has to be relieved.
Lou Holtz
The man who walked in the footsteps of Knute Rockne and restored the Irish to the former glory they’d lost in the Gerry Faust era. He won Notre Dame their last National Title, brought them their last Heisman winner and their last undefeated season. Holtz’ successors, Bob Davie, Tyrone Willingham and Charlie Weis have led the Irish to their longest sustained period of mediocrity, making them the BC of the Midwest.









“Thanks beautiful.” – Nomar
“I’m broken again.” – Nomar’s Calf
i’ll take 2 world series championships over a good shortstop anyday. (see: Yankees/Derek Jeter)
All they had to do was keep OCab and things would have been fine.
Oh and JT, you forgot ME. But you mentioned Rickey Gutierrez?
Harsh…..
Hanley Ramirez. Dominant pitching wins rings (Beckett) but the replacement was there for the “irreplaceable”
What about EP?
unfortunately you can’t even call ND the BC of the midwest, they are more like the Providence or the Holy Cross of the Midwest.
I guess the Florida Marlins are the Sox triple A of the south
DeSalvo makes a good point but the Sox still need a SS. Not really the point of the article.
StoolieMcpoyle- Hanley Ramirez is a hitter, not a SS. He is terrible defensively. Not even good. He is bad.
JT- Great blog.
AlbertDeSalvo I’ll take a good shortstop and 4 world series championships anyday (see: Yankees/Derek Jeter)
Nomar couldn’t get away from you troglodytes fast enough, just like every other significant Red Sox player in history.
You should include Will McDonough (the Globe columnist, not Tom Brady’s lackey) amongst those who are irreplaceable. The Globe sports had some real cache when they employed a guy who once knocked out an NFL cornerback, now it pretty much blows. You can bet Will would not have written an entire column whining that Tom Brady wouldn’t give him a sitdown.
Nomar hasn’t been in anybody’s line-up everyday since 2003. I’ll take the 2 rings and call it a day
Why isn’t Bobby Orr on this list?
Internet King, you need to read Mike Reiss.
Nomar Garciaparra? Is that some newfangled way to spell “Alex Gonzalez”?
Casey Tatum said: { May 28, 2009 – 04:05:33 }
troglodytes?
nice word, professor.
PS, nomar wanted to stay, we booted his ass. Good bid as usual though, now resume trying to kill yourself
The Sox are still pretty high on Lowrie…this article could prove to be premature
Seriously d-bag…Your use of that word in this case is a serious stretch. Who other significant sox player has, in your words, – ‘run away’?
Soog – Reiss is good but I’m not sure he’d knock out an NFL player because he pissed him off…I think IK was indicating that McDonough had already made his bones in the league and did what the fuck he wanted…Like Peter King with balls.
Nice Bobby Layne reference. He was originally a member of the Bears who had a couple of other guys at the time named Sid Luckman and George Blanda. 3 Hall of Fame Quarterbacks on a team at the same time, not bad!
» Brick said: { May 28, 2009 – 04:05:41 }
unfortunately you can’t even call ND the BC of the midwest, they are more like the Providence or the Holy Cross of the Midwest.
First of all, leave PC out of it… we dont even have football…. (just kidding, but seriously, we dont)
Second, i dont know why they traded Orlando Cabrera in the first place. He’s not a star, but lets face it, he was a great fielder and an average hitter. He was probably the best hitter/fielder balance the Sox have had at SS since Nomar…
Troglodytes?
Has somebody been watching the National Spelling Bee?
Like Them Apples said:
Why isn’t Bobby Orr on this list?
You can thank Ray Bourque for that.
Soog is 100% right on Mike Reiss.
Fair point JT, it’s not Borque’s fault they never gave him enough teammates to win it all. (apologies to Cam Neely and Adam Oates)
Apples,
actually, yeah they did.
If Glen Wesley couldve hit a fucking empty net from 5 feet away, the Bruins win the Cup in 1990 with Bourque, Neely, Janney and Moog.
Apples,
No knock on Bourque or Orr or any of them. The list was restricted to people who never had an adequate replacement, not someone whose team never won without him. Bourque was a pretty fair Bruins defenseman, to put it mildly.
not to digress but Orlando Cabrera was a great short stop. Not great at the plate but way better than Julio Lugo and even Edgar Renteria
(that one year). Boston could always use a huge bat at short but who couldn’t? We got Youke, Bay, Lowell, Pedroia. What they need is a solid glove, someone who will turn those double plays and not fumble the ball. Cabrera was fine we should have just stuck with him.
give me the amount of PED’s that nomar took and i’ll play every position on the field.
Well, they did have Orlando Cabrera. I heard he was pretty good. Didn’t they go somewhere that year? Oh yeah. They won the World Series.
And, they had Hanley Ramirez. I heard he was pretty good. But they traded him for Mike Lowell & Josh Beckett. How’d that work out? Oh yeah, they won another World Series and went to game 7 of the ALCS the following year.
And they had Jed Lowrie, who was the SS on the aforementioned 2007 ALCS team.
So in the post-Garciaparra Era, they’ve: Won their first world series in 86 years; Won their first division in 12 years, and gone to the playoffs three of four years, winning the division once and the World Series twice.
In fact, if you go back to 2004, the year they traded Garciaparra, they’ve won more playoff games than the Yankees and the Angels combined.
So I guess that move didn’t really pay off for them.
JErry,
Cool article dude but the whole bit about how the red sox farm system cant “solve” the shortstop problem is just wrong, what you said is pure bullshit. The best shortstop in the league (Hanley Ramirez) was in the red sox farm system. They traded him for beckett and lowell and two championships you dickhead. I assume u know that but your article indicates otherwise.
Also, the goal of baseball in the MLB is to win championships, not to have the best shortstop. It doesnt help your argument that the exact same year the sox traded nomar they won their first world series in 86 years. Yah, he probably helped them in a few games that year but its now widely know that the guy was a fuckin cancer to the team.
Next time you want to let your readers know that you want to suck nomars dick, just say so, dont waste everyones time with a bullshit “most irreplaceable people” list. next time, a picture of you with nomars dick in your mouth will suffice
I want Tejada … he is in the final year of his contract … Houston is already 9 games out … he is batting .349
Ahem, Jerry – remember the last guy to achieve the triple crown.
No respect I tells ya.
The Sox should have kept A-Gon. I’ll take a .275 hitting shortstop who plays nearly flawless defense. Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how you look at it) Nomar was done when the Sox sent him across the field to Minn. back in ’04. Sorta like a carton of milk that you get 2 extra days out of after the experation date, it’s good that it lasted but one morning you’re gonna be pour chunks onto your Capt. Crunch. As for O-Cab, he would have been a good replacement except for his complete inability to keep his dick out of other players wives.
*pouring… sorry.
Thebigneon
i know you tend to blow up in people’s faces and use profanity to get your point across, so i’ll do this as inpartially as possible…
Hanley Ramirez was not, and is not in the least bit, the best SS in the league. He has had over 20 errors in every one of his seasons with the marlins (none in 2 games with the Red Sox). He only has 3 this year, but that could change in the dog days of the summer. When you look at a guy like Derek Jeter (As a Sox fan, i can say that he is truly the best SS in the league in terms of fielding/hitting ballance), he has only had 20+ error seasons TWICE in his 14 year career. If you want to call Hanley Ramirez the best SS at the dish, I’ll say that’s a fair assumption, but he is not the best all around SS in the league.
I agree with almost everything else you said. I dont think the point of this article is to show that El Prez wants to suck Nomar’s dick. The point was put across fine. It’s true, since Nomar (with the exception of the year when he came back from his injury) the Sox have not had a great defensive shortstop who produced at the dish like Nomar did.
jerry wrote the article, jerry wants to suck nomar’s D
jeter is literally the worst fielding shortstop in the league, this is not my opinion, its a proven fact) see:
http://www.nypost.com/seven/02162008/sports/yankees/study_claims_jeter_is_worst_fielding_sho_97934.htm
i never said it wasnt true that the sox havent had a good hitting shortstop, that is an indisputable fact