This conflict should be judged in two, distinct portions. The first half we’ll call the “debate” portion, and the second we’ll refer to as the “fisticuffs.” In the debate section, it appears early on as if the Black lady is scoring points with the audience through a calm presentation of her arguments, laying out the facts in a concise way and cleverly framing the issue with context. Though the Asian lady came back nicely with her emotional appeal and the phrase “You are STUPID!” which I think is the sound bite everyone will remember tomorrow. As for the fisticuffs segment, it was not even a contest. Black lady landed the first blow but from then on it was all Asian lady, all the time. The referee would’ve stopped the contest before it ever got to the judges. Though in fairness, Black lady was fighting way out of her weight class.  Somehow though, I can’t picture cities using this video as an ad for public transportation.

(Thanks to Alanna.)